Grades 9-12

What Should the U.S. Spend Its Money On?

Economics is grounded in the concept of scarcity, which ultimately means there is not enough stuff (e.g., food, movie theaters, healthcare) to go around. As a result, economic reasoning emphasizes making informed decisions about how to distribute goods and services efficiently and in ways that yield the best outcomes. It seems like a straightforward process, but this process is value laden — What do individuals value?  How should we reconcile different values?  This inquiry lesson sets the stage for wrestling with competing priorities at both the macro and personal levels.

D2.Eco.1.9-12. Analyze how incentives influence choices that may result in policies with a range of costs and benefits for different groups.

Featured Sources

Source A:  Budget Priority Cards

Source B:  Policy Basics: Where do our federal tax dollars go?” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 2023

Formative Performance Tasks

  1. DELIBERATE: Rank order the Budget Priority cards from #1-10 based on how you think the government should spend its money.
  2. COLLABORATE: Pair up with a classmate and compare rank orders noting differences between each other’s ranking.  Input rankings in a google form.
  3. PRODUCE: Compare your rankings with the actual US budget and note the difference/s between student priorities and national priorities.

Instructional Snapshot

Begin class with a collaborative sorting exercise in which students work to prioritize 10 cards (Source A) that have competing budget priorities on them. For example, one card features an image of U.S. soldiers with the caption: “MILITARY: Spending for national defense and support for U.S. allies and interests abroad.” Another card reads, “HEALTH CARE: Spending for research to cure or prevent disease and services for low-income and elderly Americans.” Students are then asked the question, “What should we spend our money on?” and in small groups deliberate which order to place the cards (e.g., Military, Healthcare, Education, Environment) — 15 minutes. Then, students put their rankings into a Google form and examine in real time how the entire class ranks the various priorities — 10 minutes. The teacher might end the class with students examining a pie chart of the current budget priorities to compare their priority list with the reality of the U.S. Budget — 10 minutes. Students may be surprised at how little proportionally the government spends on education.

The Heart of Social Studies

Inquiries

What Should the U.S. Spend Its Money On? Economics is grounded in the concept of scarcity, which ultimately means there is not enough stuff (e.g., food, movie theaters, healthcare) to go around. As a result, economic reasoning emphasizes making informed decisions about how to distribute goods and services efficiently and in ways that yield the…

This inquiry leads students through an investigation of tribal sovereignty for existing Native American tribes and nations in the United States and their continuing relationship with the federal government as a nation-to-nation agreement as defined within each and every treaty made with the more than 574 recognized American Indian and Alaska Native tribes and villages…

This inquiry leads students through an investigation of Guatemala’s recent history, with emphasis on the coup of 1954, and the resulting effects that ripple into the present. At the center of this project is the question: How can we pursue justice? This compelling question is explored in the context of Guatemala’s history and the advocates…

This inquiry leads students through an investigation of questions around Indigenous People’s land rights. Focusing on the construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAPL), students explore how disputes over treaties and historical land bases complicate the already contentious issue of resource extraction. Students are progressively introduced to land rights issues centering on the experiences of…

In this inquiry, students investigate police and policing reform in historical and modern contexts. Framed by the compelling questionㄧHow should we reform policing?ㄧstudents explore the form and function of policing in order to evaluate reforms and create their own reform policy proposal. First, students examine the purpose of policing, considering the role police play in…

Filed Under:

This inquiry asks students to explore issues of individual responsibility and moral choice by investigating the compelling question, “I was only following orders! Is this an acceptable defense?” Students will consider Dr. Solis’s question about actions taken during the Holocaust and more as they study the history of the “superior orders” defense from its first…

This inquiry leads students through an investigation of how they can make an impact on their community. By investigating the compelling question, students examine an issue that is important to them, assess what can be done to help with the issue, plan ways they can take action on their issue, and evaluate potential challenges. By…

This inquiry leads students through an investigation of Sikhism and the challenges and opportunities the Sikh community has faced over time. By investigating the compelling question “How do religious communities respond to challenges and opportunities?” students evaluate how the Sikh community has responded to different social, historical, and political changes as members immigrated and integrated…

This inquiry leads students through an investigation that examines the purpose and effects of gun legislation in the United States. In doing so, it provides students with the opportunity to critically examine the motives behind gun laws and the disproportionate impact of gun violence on Black and Latinx communities. Although this compelling question seems straightforward,…

This inquiry leads students through an investigation of global citizenship, global cooperation, as well as how local solutions have been used to solve shared global issues. The inquiry is designed to open students’ eyes to their role as global citizens. It is also designed for students to uncover the similarities in issues faced by rural…